Garlic Knots – Tying together the Past & the Present
For 10 years my working life was swallowed up by a cafe/market where we made some of the most badass garlic knots around. Those combined with an espresso were my regular sustenance on countless non-stop, never pause for a breath days.
Garlic Knots Recipe
Screw the labor laws with required break-times, as a GM there is too much to be done in too short of a time. The garlic knots were the perfect grab-&-go nosh. I never got tired of them, never even tired of their beautiful aroma coming out of the kitchen like clock work, every day at 9:00 a.m

During this same time, I became obsessed with making breads. When we remodeled our first townhouse’s kitchen, we put in a section of countertop which was lower just so it would be easier to knead bread. However, despite these two loves flying together in my life at the same moment, I never once made garlic knots at home.
Past to Present
Fast forward to recent history; the years in the restaurant business are quietly tucked under years of photography work, my bread making passion had calmed giving way for other culinary explorations. However in the last couple years, due to blogging and certain clients of ours, the bread making mojo has been roused. There is rarely a moment when we don’t have some par-baked pizza crusts ready in the freezer and a batch of basic dough sleeping in the second fridge.

Through experimenting with techniques and observing our favorite bakeries production, I started letting go of the need to knead the dough into submission. It is necessary for some types of bread textures, but not for the softer, lighter textures we often seek. This mindset was further validated by chefs we met who had fantastic bread, as well of course by our community favorite, Artisan Bread in 5 Minutes a Day. Bread making suddenly became simple, with quick prep times, and ever delicious results.

cheese cloth over knots during their rise
Diane said she was craving garlic knots. How could I not be after all the days those little bread beasts kept my stomach at bay and stirred by the fond memories of the ever-smiling Felix tossing the knots and bringing into them into the market still warm and room filling aromatic.
Making bread has a special life to it. Once the yeast activates, it becomes a living thing. I still can’t help but think of Bourdain’s recollection of an insanely talented but crazy baker who would call up in a stupor, “Feed the Bitch.. Feed her or she’ll die!” I tend to have a less crass attitude towards my doughs (and women). They are beautiful, nourishing, and ever a part of my life.
-Todd

How to Make Garlic Knots
Here’s some tips which I’ve found help make things easier when making these garlic knots.
1. Use a Scale. By using a scale you seriously cut down on clean up (just 1 bowl & 1 spoon needed to make dough!) and it is more accurate. It also makes it easier to substitute other flours, since the weight ratios usually don’t change much but volume does.
2. Chilled dough (even 15-20 min.) will be easier to handle than a freshly risen one (it is ok to still use the fresh one though)
3. I love our flour sack towels for covering the dough when proofing.
4. Oil and flour both are invaluable to keep dough from sticking. Usually I’ll use one or the other, but in the forming of the knots I liked using both in coordination. Oil the board, your hands, and rolling dowel to flatten dough into a rectangle. Slice into 3/4″ strips, then dust board and dough w/ flour to roll into a rope and knot. The oil is great on the outer surfaces of the knots giving a crisper crust when baking, but by using only oil when forming the knots, the dough slips and starts to stick to itself. The flour makes the rolling and knotting easier. If there is too much flour and it glides around when making the ropes, just dust of excess flour from the board.
…Everyone help settle a friendly dispute for us. Which technique do you prefer?

Above: Diane prefers to brush her garlic knots with the garlic butter. Below: Todd likes pouring the garlic butter onto the knots and tossing them inside the bowl.

Garlic Knot Recipe
Ingredients
Dough
- 1 3/4 cups (415ml) Warm Water (@115°F)
- 1/4 cup (60ml) Olive Oil
- 1 teaspoon (5g) Kosher Salt
- 1 Tablespoon (15g) Sugar
- 1 1/2 Tablespoons (17g) Active Dry Yeast (or 2 active dry yeast packages)
- 5 1/2 cup (700g) all-purpose, unbleached Flour , approx.
Garlic Coating
- 2 Tablespoons (30ml) Olive Oil
- 2 Tablespoons (30g) unsalted Butter
- 4 cloves Garlic , finely minced or crushed
- 1/4 cup (60ml) finely chopped fresh Italian Parsley
- Kosher Salt to taste
- plus extra Olive Oil and Flour for making the knots
Instructions
- Combine water, 1/4 cup (55g) olive oil, salt, sugar, and active dry yeast in a large resealable container or bowl. Mix to dissolve yeast.
- Add flour. Mix to incorporate flour, cover, and set in a warm spot to proof until doubled in volume (usually 1-3 hrs depending on initial water temp and warmth of proofing area). (A sunny table outside on a warm summer day is perfect for proofing!)
- Chill the dough for a bit (will keep fine in fridge for several days if you want to make the dough ahead of time) to make it easier to handle (this can be skipped if you don't have the time) then set up your knotting station. Put out a large wooden cutting board and oil liberally. Grab a rolling dowel or pin and oil. Grab a pizza cutter or something similar to slice dough in strips. Put container of flour within easy reach. Line several sheet pans with parchment paper and place within easy reach.
- Oil your hands to help keep dough from sticking to them. Divide the dough in two parts to make it easier to handle. Take the first half and roll out into an even rectangle approx. 5"x16" and about 1/2" thick. Slice the rectangle into 1/2" wide x 5" long strips.
- Sprinkle dough strips and board with flour. Taking the strip nearest to you, roll it back and forth to create an even rope. Tie into a knot (loop the dough and then take one end over and through the loop) and place on lined sheet pan. Place knots about an 1 1/2" apart. At first it may seem awkward making the knots but with a little practice it will become easy. Flour is your friend to help keep the dough from sticking to itself while forming the knots.
- Continue making the rest of the knots with the second half of the dough. After each sheet pan fills up, cover with a dry sack towel, and place in a warm, draft-free spot to rise.
- Preheat oven to 400° F.
- After knots have doubled in size, take off the towel and place knots in the oven. Bake for approx. 12-15 minutes or until golden.
- While knots are baking, make garlic coating. Gently warm olive oil, butter, and garlic in a small saucepan (if you like your garlic with less of a bite, cook it for a few minutes in oil/butter mix until soft & slightly golden). Add chopped parsley and set aside.
- After removing knots from oven, while still warm, either brush with garlic coating, or place knots in a large bowl and toss with garlic coating. Season with salt to taste. Best served warm, but still good when at room temp.



I just made this tonight! Great recipe! I found that I needed a lot more of the garlic and parsely to cover the bread, so I just added 2 more tablespoons of butter to the pot. Also, I added freshly grated Parmesan cheese to it instead of the salt. It added a great taste of flavor!
Thanks soooo much for the recipe!
I see you decided to roll out your dough into a rectangle. Once you cut the strips did you roll it back into a ball. The strips look pretty flat and I’m not sure how I could roll it out into a rope when it’s already pretty thin. Could you also just weigh out your dough by amount of units and roll out from there..or did you find rolling it into a rectangle resulted in a better texture?
Thanks for your help
Hi Jackie,
After cutting the dough into strips, I rolled each strip into a rope. With a touch of flour, it was quite easy. If you wanted to weigh out each dough ball and roll from there, that should work quite well, too. I’ll often do that when I make dinner rolls. I chose to do it this way for the garlic knots because it was faster for me to do the larger quantities. Either way should give you a good texture as long as you don’t over work the dough.
Hope that helps.
Todd
Anthony’s Place is a Italian restaurant in sheepshead bay Brooklyn NY .Formally the Pizza Bowl since 1947 .Garlic Rolls are served with every entree. to my knowledge, The pizza bowl was the first to introduce garlic rolls today some call garlic nots . If anyone knows of any other history prior 1947 please post .Thank You. Anthony.
I made these the other day and they were amazing! Im a novice when it comes to making bread, but my family went nuts.
Oh and I tried both methods, and brushing, then pouring the garlic over them is the best option.
I do have a question though, these made a lot of knots, and for a family of 4, I found myself saving dough till the next day. Can the knots be formed and frozen, or will they not rise again?
You are great!
Brilliant! I enjoyed reading your post and I can’t wait to try the recipe…
Made these tonight for a potluck pizza making party I’m throwing tomorrow. SO DELICIOUS.. I already ate a handful before I could stop myself. Thank you for the post and the pictures are amazing.
I just used these to teach my sister how to make bread, they turned out great! So easy to make and so yum. Thanks for the great recipe and for inspiring others to learn! 🙂
I used a container of refrigerated dough, tied into knots, then used your garlic topping. They were awesome!
A couple of questions as these suckers bake: 1) the dough seemed a bit dry on the first rise, despite having added a bit of extra water (I’m using instant yeast and the package advised a tad more water than with regular active yeast). Is this normal? I used a scale to measure ingredients, so I’m fairly certain I got the proportions right. 2) The knots are baking now and they’re taking an extra 10-15 minutes in the oven to reach that golden color. My oven thermometer reports 400F. (I’m using a gas oven.) I let the knots rise for an hour or so in a 70F room – maybe they should have had more time? I’m looking forward to the results, thanks for the recipe.
The dough definitely isn’t a wet dough. It should be easy to handle with just a little flour. “Dry” is such a relative term in regards to doughs, it is hard to say if it is “normal” or not without seeing it. Some flour will absorb liquids more than others, so you may have to adjust for the flour you buy.
To tell if a dough has risen enough, you can always give them a little poke. If the dent stays, it had risen enough. If it springs back then it needs to rise more. Hope they turn out well for you.
I definitely did something wrong – maybe not a long enough rise initially, and I’m thinking more water next time too. These knots came out very dry and dense, more like crackers than bread. There were a few that approached the right consistency but overall I wasn’t pleased. Looking back at your pics I’m thinking my dough had less spring to it – the strips were limp and flat, unlike your puffy strips.
I’d start with just less flour. Even when going by weight, flour will vary a bit. Start with maybe 1 c, or 150g less flour, then just add 1/4c or so at a time after the initial set is incorporated, and keep adding until it seems right. Try handling the dough as little as possible too. Over kneading or over working when making the knots will make the crumb more dense, too. Maybe try changing yeast, as well.
Good luck on the next batch.
T
hi! when i go to divide the dough in half, is it okay to freeze one half?? I’m only cooking for 2, and 40 knots seem like a bit much 🙂 thanks!
You could, but we didn’t like how this dough cooked that well after freezing. It was ok, but not as good as the original. The uncooked dough actually keeps very well in the fridge. Put it in an air-tight container and it will keep well for a good week or two. After that it is still good, but the flavor will start to become more of a sour-dough bread, and doesn’t match up with the garlic knots as well. Though it will make a good loaf!
oh okay, that’s great! THANKS!
I made these tonight and it was great. So great indeed that I had to run to my friends house so that she could eat some as well. I am happy knowing that there is still a lot of dough left in the fridge to try some more tomorrow. Thank you very much for this post. You are the most encouraging food blog I have read and I do read a lot!
Made these tonight and the family RAVED! Thanks so much for a tasty and easy treat! Went a whole ‘nuther direction with the garlic oil – tossed them in a gallon ziplock! Abundant and even coating – YUM!
I was going to make brioche, this evening, but I am tempted to change my plans and make these tasty rolls. Let’s see what wins.
Hello. Thanks for the post! I live in an apartment and it is rainy here often. Instead of setting the dough to rise outside as you suggested, is there a way I can keep it warm in the oven, like if the temperature was set to its lowest mark? If so, what temp is best? Thanks!
I LOVE this knots and my family also loved them! thanks!!! easy, tasty, abundant, perfect for a party…
These are soo delicious and ADDICTING! C&O in Venice Beach has one of the best garlic knots. You cannot get sick of them… making them quite dangerous!